It is really well built and has the softest down cushion imaginable, which my very pregnant body appreciated after a long day at the auctions.
The fabric is in bad shape though, so new upholstery is in the chair's not-so-distant future. Trouble is I can't decide whether or not to ditch the channel design. Would you believe that I couldn't find a single channel back chair in my design files? Obviously this style is not super en vogue, but can it still be considered chic?
Either way, I want the new vibe of the chair to be modern and spunky. I'm hoping for something as cool as this red-trimmed striped number from Erinn Valencich.
What say you? Rock the channel or go for a straight back?
I have a pair of chairs that look identical(without the nailhead though) that I inherited from my grandmother. They are my favorite pieces of furniture that I have. I absolutely love everything about them except for the fabric. I too need to reupholster mine. Love that picture of the striped chair. I hadn't thought about putting a striped fabric on them. -Cristi
ReplyDeleteI vote to keep the channel!
ReplyDeleteKeep the channel! It is beautiful!
ReplyDeleteI say keep the channels . If you can t find any examples thats great it means its unusual and will be a talking point and no one will be able to copy you !
ReplyDeleteI have a funny feeling they'll be back "in" soon. They do have an appeal, but there's something about the channels that I don't like. Maybe it's the thought of what can lost or found in them and the collection of dust that can accumulate. Sorry, I don't have OCD but rather a family with severe allergies. LOL!
ReplyDeleteMy vote is to keep the channels. I agree with ZoeB that the chairs will be unique if you are unable to find many examples.
ReplyDeleteI can't wait to see the finished product. I know it will be gorgeous!
KEEP THE CHANNELS!!!! I am an upholsterer and often see the fabulous details eliminated when pieces are redone. Keep it true to the original design, it will be a one of a kind!
ReplyDeletetotally rock the channels! :D
ReplyDeleteI've seen a couple of new channel backs recently...I think they'll make a comeback. They're classic and add interest. Only trouble is that it'll affect your fabric choices...great find! I love those old down cushions, just so cozy!
ReplyDeleteKEEP THE CHANNELS! I've actually been trying to find one in good shape for ages! Consider yourself lucky to have found one that was also free!
ReplyDeleteTuft the back. The frame's upper inside is probably not nice enough to be showing (like the chair in the picture). The tufting is also a good DIY. The channels will cost you more in labor and fabric.
ReplyDeleteI actually love the channels, but whenever you see one at the antique store they always have dust/dirt in each of the groves. Not kid friendly.
You can always have it changed back later.
depends on the fabric choice as to whether or not I would keep the channel. also, you really do have a great eye (do I really need to say that? your blog is wonderful), the silhouette of the chair is fantastic. can't wait to see what you do with it.
ReplyDeleteIt would be way easier to upholster without the channel... that's always a plus...Nice chair, can't wait to see what you do!
ReplyDeleteI recently picked one of these babies up for free too! I love the channeling and the comfy down. It needs to be reupholstered and I'm thinking of going straight backed - mostly because it wouldn't be as challenging for me to do myself. But I'm loving these chairs seen here --
ReplyDeletehttp://indiefixx.com/2009/09/23/a-peek-inside-indie-home-tours-with-amanda-blake-soule-of-soule-mama/
and I think channels are a beautiful detail. Can't wait to see what you do with your lovely chair!
If you do something incredible with this chair, I'm going to kick myself! I saw an almost identical one at a yard sale a few weeks ago that I passed up. . . wasn't sure if I wanted to bother with the expense of reupholstering. Anyway, I would definitely keep the channel back; makes it so much more feminine. Love love the painted trim in the picture. Can't wait to see it!
ReplyDeleteNot sure how difficult it would be to do this as I'm definitely not an upholsterer, but what if you did 2 different fabrics and alternated each fabric on each channel? It sounds like it'd be a bitch to do, but I think the end result would be stunning. I think it would definitely give it a modern twist on a classic piece, which is one of my favorite design themes in my home.
ReplyDeleteOh keep the channels! But that means that you can't do a stripe, unless you get really good and have each channel be a different color. Good find. I lOVE it! I would go gray with a yellow trim.....but that's for my house :)
ReplyDeleteChannel!
ReplyDeleteRock the channel! I love that chair and can't wait to see what you do with it!
ReplyDeleteOld world details like that are hard to find. I know you could give it a new life and make that chair sing!
ReplyDeletepve
This is going to be so much fun! I say keep the channel unless it is super complicated to re-cover.
ReplyDeleteI would keep the channels if you're having a pro do it. DIY that would be a PAIN. I would consider eliminating 2 channels to make each one a little wider. That's just my personal preference. I'm sure you will make a gorgeous choice with it.
ReplyDeletei think it'll depend on what fabric you choose. if you are going with a solid, keep the channel back. if you opt for a patterned fabric, then you will lose some of the pattern in the folds, so i would do straight back. both are beautiful though! can't wait to see the end result.
ReplyDeletegrace
Keep the channel. Anything you touch is en vouge!
ReplyDeleteKeep the channels - very unique BUT if you want to change it, tuffed with buttons would be wonderful too. L-U-C-K-Y. Are you going to re-upholster yourself? If so, take lots of photos!
ReplyDeleteI say Rock the Channel!
ReplyDeleteI just had to come out of the woods when I saw you chair... I too just got one for free! I have no idea what to do with it, but Im thinking a solid "mustard" yellow...I know nothing of design so tell me your plans!
ReplyDeleteLove your blog!
Jimena, from Peru
Rock the channel!!
ReplyDeleteTock the channel! It's so interesting.
ReplyDeleteoops, that should say "rock", not "tock". :)
ReplyDeleteIf you like the channel then DO IT!
ReplyDeleteCan't wait to see what you do with this one! I know it's going to be amazing.
ReplyDeleteI have a channel back chair (also free!) that I have had for 14 years. It desperately needs reupolstering as the seat is torn but I have just tucked an old quilt top on the seat because I can't find directions for channel upolstering. So I guess since I've been holding out for so long my vote is for the channels!!
ReplyDeleteRock it with red piping in the channeling seams!
ReplyDeleteKeep the channel! Great detail that should not be lost! I think it would make the stripes look even cooler!
ReplyDeleteKeep the channels!! I have a this type of chair in my bedroom at home and love the channels. It's what gives it character! You can see it here: http://www.dreamindomestic.com/2009/09/06/home-room/
ReplyDeleteI think because you have no similar pictures in your design files that you should do something different and keep the channels!
Rock the channel!!! I agree with the idea to alternate a solid color with a print, then paint the legs the same solid color and lacquer up those babies. Say... got any of that Chinese dragon fabric left? ;-)
ReplyDeleteJenny,
ReplyDeleteCheck out this photo: http://www.re-nest.com/re-nest/interview/molly-worth-of-chairloom-reuse-and-reinvent-renest-interview-097633
Very similar in shape to your chair. Recovered in Hable Construction fabric. Love it.
Also try searching google images for "channel back chair" for some inspiration. The channels are not for everyone--but they are what separates this chair from a thousand others.
Keep the channel back! Great find!
ReplyDeleteCottage Living had a channel back redone somewhere near the end of the mag-- the feature where all the editors showed a chair they re-upholstered (yes, I'm a huge dork for knowing this)-- I feel like whoever did it DID keep the channels, but I can't remember for sure. I am kind of partial to flat backs myself, though.
ReplyDeleteMy mother in law always sat in one of these - sorry to say no one wanted it back in the day... it would be so pretty to recover now. Sigh...Jennifer
ReplyDeleteI think the channel back is fun, although it will limit your choices in fabric design. I can't wait to see what you come up with!
ReplyDeleteI definitely say rock the channel. It's such a great detail-but my vote changes if you end up running stripes...i feel like they would compete with the channel lines and the silhouette will lose effect.
ReplyDeleteHey, if the fabric is modern and spunky, I think it'd be such a fab contrast with the channel backing. It's wonderful!
ReplyDeleteGeez, I PAID $30 for a chair like this. Did I get ripped off or what?!
ReplyDeleteSo of course I vote for you to keep the channels so I can see what you did. And copy it!
Kristen W. in Atlanta
I guess I am in the minority. I say lose the channels! I love the chair you are using for inspiration! Great find! I love the free finds at auctions!
ReplyDeleteThis is a great chair, love the channeling, it's classic, but you could put a spin to it and make it only 5 wider ones, how 'bout that?
ReplyDeleteThen sink in it with baby and all!
XX
Victoria
Rock the channel! I think it adds an interesting dimension, and without it, it might be kind of boring! Can't wait to see what you decide!
ReplyDeleteI also have a channel back chair inherited from my grandmother. She always called it a barrel back chair...don't know if that helps. I love my chair and find it very comfortable. I use it at my desk and you would be amazed at how many times none of my four daughters know where I am because I am hidden behind the chair!! Wonderful! So I vote - Keep the barrel back!
ReplyDeleteI say ROCK the CHANNEL- it's so different. LGN, Your bringing CHANNEL back... open the floodgates.
ReplyDeleteI love the channels even though I've never seen a chair like this before. You're one to be a trendsetter! Do it!
ReplyDeleteRock the channel Jen...
ReplyDeleteMy Grandmother had 2 of those chairs...loved them.
Kathy :)
I say keep! It's a fun detail that will make your chair unique :).
ReplyDeleteRock the channels, girl!
ReplyDeleteIt's going to look so awesome when you're done---can't wait to see! : )
All puff and tuff is so back so definitely keep it.
ReplyDeleteYou are very lucky with your auction find.
X
V
rock the channel, it will work. you will find a way!
ReplyDeleteIt seems to me that it would depend quite a bit on the fabric that you choose. A large pattern would look best without but something more simple would benefit from the extra detail. I think keep it with the channel, you'll be glad you did in the long run.
ReplyDeleteChAnNEL!!
ReplyDeleteRock the channel! Go to Design Sponge blog and look at the cute before & after with a similar chair redone in a Thomas Paul fabric...super cute!!
ReplyDeleteKeep the channel!!
ReplyDeleteRock the channels, sista!!!!
ReplyDeleteI have a dressing table chair so similar to this. The channeled back is about 10 inches high and it is on a swivel seat. I LOVE it & have been considering what fabric to get for my little jewel. (Right now it is covered in a patterned rose-pink chenille. I will anxiously await your changes for the chair you found. I know it will be great!
Pat B.
I would keep the channel back and accentuate it with a slightly shiny fabric, something in a silk mix or a polished cotton, to give it a very 40's Hollywood glamour.
ReplyDeletelove it !
ReplyDeleteAre you crazy? Don't even consider getting rid of the channels. Character and class are never out of style.
ReplyDeleteKeep!
ReplyDeleteLove the stripe with red trim. I am excited that you chose this chair.
ReplyDeletechannel.
ReplyDeleteI guess I'm the oddball here....I prefer the pic you posted without the channels. Definitely an easier project. Anticipating the final masterpiece! Good Luck!
ReplyDeletei found this channel back redone on etsy (for an arm and a leg)
ReplyDeletehttp://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=33502053 ...
i think a solid channel back would be beautiful but a print might get lost.
keep the channel, with a modern fabric it will look incredible!!!
ReplyDeleteKeep the channel!
ReplyDeleteKeep the channel! It's reminiscent of a bygone era. I'd like to see it in a solid pop of color.
ReplyDeleteI've tagged you!!! You've just received the Honest Scrap Award!!!
ReplyDeletePlease check my blog, link back and start spilling the thruth!
XX
Victoria
Keep the channel. It'll be a nice textural feel even with a solid fabric, or add to any pattern you choose (I think big and splashy would be fun.)
ReplyDeleteIt is beautiful! Work from home India
ReplyDeleteAmazingly I found almost the exact same chair at a yard sale this weekend. She wanted $40 for it-I do not know how to reupholster and got too scared of the idea of taking the project on. I LOVE your blog! I love estate/yard sales and love to visualize new ideas for previously loved furniture/accessories. I'm planning on painting a darling table I picked up for $10 a while back a teal color-plan on taking my shoe in to Lowe's for them to match the color this week! Maybe I'll send you a picture.
ReplyDeleteBecky in Florida
Keep the channels, they really aren't that hard to upholster (I've done it on one inherited from my grandmother). I would suggest using a stripe or a print for the back and possibly the sides of the chair and using a coordinating solid for the front, including the channels. It's a beautiful chair.
ReplyDeleteI am also looking for a high back wing type chair! Personally, I like the straight back, but obviously it's personal preference...
ReplyDeleteKeep the channel, its unique! Super cool find! So jealous!
ReplyDeleteLove,love,love, the chair and the channels!!! I like the feminine graceful back and the more masculine tacks all in one great chair....I think a fabric wth some sheen would be the ticket....love the baby bump. jw
ReplyDeleteyou can't specify what people say silly girl; was going to just say ditch the channels, but your little editorial advisement is annoying.
ReplyDeleteI wanted to share this one with you -there is a whole bunch going on here.... but it's definately modern and different!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.stylehive.com/bookmark/charleston-chair-112938
ohhh ROCK THE CHANNEL!
ReplyDeleteJust wondering what fabric you ended up covering your channel back chair in - any pictures?! Thanks!
ReplyDeletekeep the channels but be careful that they do not bulk it up too much and lose the softness of the chair.
ReplyDeleteSince i am getting ready to have my grandfather's channel-backed chair recover I have been checking and rechecking your site to see what you decided on. My chair is very similar except I have wood trim on the back and arms. Update please :)
ReplyDeleteI'm sitting here with a channel back chair behind me that I also got for free! I love this chair and wanted to reuphoulster it myself but decided that it was WAY out of my skill level with the channels. I'm keeping them though, such character! I'm in the process of looking for a cool graphic print but will be paying someone to do this for me. Can't wait to see yours when finished!
ReplyDeletehttp://bncgrimes.blogspot.com/2010/07/reading-chair.html
I do hope you kept the channels. I now have 3, 2 free and one purchased at Salvation Army I think for under $20--it was on a half price sale. I really want to slipcover or reupholster all 3 to match.
ReplyDeleteI vote to keep the channel back. I have one and would like another. I recently had it reupholstered in an off white heavy textured material. It is gorgeous and so very comfortable. Even the men love to sit in it
ReplyDelete